Do You Remember Red Diesel?
Half a million crowns for a trace in the tank. That is exactly what red diesel cost in the wrong place, regardless of whether it got there deliberately or by mistake. From our time in the customs administration, we remember it from the “state” side, and to this day I consider its story the best textbook on how tax advantages are designed – and how they go wrong.

How it worked
From 2004 until the end of 2010, a reduced rate of excise duty applied to marked gas oils. The legal framework was provided by Act No. 98/2004 Coll. on excise duty on mineral oil, which in Section 7 of its original wording laid down a reduced rate of SKK 6,800 per 1,000 litres, approximately EUR 226. In practice, this meant a litre for roughly EUR 0.83 instead of the later EUR 1.25 – with hundreds of thousands of litres a year, a difference that determined the economics of an entire agricultural cooperative.
The advantage came with one condition: the designated purpose. The Act defined it precisely in Section 7, and farmers were not alone in it. Red diesel could also be used as fuel for heat production, to power rail vehicles in railway transport and to run the engines of stationary electricity-generating equipment, so locomotives and generators filled up with it too. The centre of gravity of the system – and of almost all its problems – nevertheless lay in the fields. For machinery, the Act allowed red diesel only for work in agricultural production of a productive nature or services carried out in the course of business, and exclusively so. It was never allowed to end up in the tank of an ordinary motor vehicle on the road. To make this enforceable, the fuel was marked with a red dye and a marker substance. Only registered user undertakings could purchase it, every machine had to be registered, every rental and every transfer had to be reported, and storage facilities needed an authorisation. Large cooperatives managed this with their own storage tanks; small farmers could not afford such capacity and drove their machines straight to filling stations to refuel. There was a lot of paperwork. And at the end of the chain stood customs officers with sampling kits.
Why everyone remembers it
Tanks were checked both in the fields and on the roads. In the field, this was done by mobile control units known by the acronym KOMOS: they stopped a tractor or a car, took a sample from the tank and knew the test result on the spot. And here is the detail for which even people who had nothing to do with agriculture remember red diesel: the marker was practically impossible to remove from a tank. Traces remained identifiable for a very long time, even after ordinary diesel had been filled up repeatedly. Anyone who had once filled up with red diesel, deliberately or by mistake, had no way of hiding it. And the sanction made no distinction between intent and a canister that someone had mislabelled in the garage.
Nor was it just any sanction. For using marked gas oil contrary to its designated purpose, the Act imposed a fine of half a million crowns, almost EUR 16,600, at a fixed amount. No administrative discretion, no grading by quantity, circumstances or degree of fault. For a large company a painful cost; for a small farmer a ruinous sum. The customs administration publicly warned about it and enforced the fines, including through enforcement proceedings.
The harshest part, however, was that the Act contained no provision to mitigate its own severity. No power of moderation, no possibility of reducing or waiving the fine, even though with these fines in particular this would have been more than justified in many cases. Whoever imposed the fine had no choice, even when the case began with an obvious mistake and ended with the survival of a family farm at stake. Stories arose that can only be called tragic, and nothing at all could be done about them.
That leaves the question of what was actually considered to be the presence of red diesel. The Act knew no lower threshold. The presence of the dye and the marker was determined by the procedure under technical standard STN 65 6082, and the marking itself was designed to survive dilution. The marker Solvent Yellow 124 was added at a concentration of at least six milligrams per litre, and the red colouring had to remain visible even in a mixture of one part marked and ten parts unmarked diesel. Moreover, the Act explicitly prohibited diluting, removing or otherwise altering the marking. The interpretation was therefore unforgiving: if the test found the marker, even in a trace amount from a fill-up long since used, marked gas oil had been present in the tank and had been used contrary to its purpose. A trace meant presence. And presence meant half a million.
Nor did the strictness end with what someone had in their tank. For machinery, the Act required exclusive use in agricultural production, and that word was taken literally. In practice, we dealt with cases where a tractor that had ploughed and brought in the harvest all season once, exceptionally, transported material over a short distance or helped out with work only indirectly related to agriculture. A single such trip was enough for the exclusivity condition to fail. The same machine, the same diesel in the tank – and suddenly use contrary to the designated purpose, with everything that came with it: additional taxation and a fine. Cooperatives thus learned that the question is not what the machine is, but what it is doing at the moment.
Today we would say that the state built the control mechanism directly into the product. Chemistry provided the evidence; the patrol did the rest.
Why it ended
Two reasons: abuse and money. Trafficking in the advantage never stopped, and the system was administratively costly for both sides. In the crisis year of 2010, the state expected roughly EUR 100 million a year from abolishing it, and Parliament abolished the advantage at the end of 2010 despite a petition with 115,000 signatures. Red diesel thus existed until 31 December 2010. Farmers were given the first fifteen days of the new year to use up their stocks, followed by a stocktaking and additional taxation of the difference for fuel in storage as well as in machine tanks.
What replaced it
At first, nothing. Apart from one-off aid in 2013, when Act No. 33/2013 Coll. allowed a subsidy of EUR 0.153 per litre up to a volume of 65 million litres, farmers were left without support for years. A systemic solution came only in 2019 under the name Green Diesel (Zelená nafta): state aid under which a farmer fills up with ordinary, fully taxed diesel and the state subsequently refunds part of the excise duty through the Agricultural Paying Agency, based on the declared area of land and the livestock kept. The fuel no longer has any special colour, and nobody checks your tank on a farm track. In 2024, more than EUR 32 million was paid out in this way to almost three thousand applicants.
The two systems are a textbook contrast. Red diesel gave the advantage at the pump and built control into the product, into the dye and the patrols. Green diesel gives the advantage in the data and has moved control into applications and records. Neither is free; each simply pays with a different kind of cost. The question in designing tax rules is never whether to control. It is where in the chain to place the control.
And it is not dead yet
The principle of marking lives on in Europe, especially for heating oils. On 19 January 2024, the common European marker even changed: Accutrace Plus replaced Solvent Yellow, while the red colour remains. The practical consequence for anyone driving a diesel car around Europe: cheap Heizöl at a German pump is still the same trap as our red diesel once was. And in Act No. 98/2004 Coll., the logic of tax-advantaged oil lives on to this day in the instruments of the user undertaking and the purchase permit for LPG or heating oils. Red diesel did not die. It just changed commodities.
Do you remember it? And if so, from which side: did you fill up, check, calculate the additional tax, or were you the one being checked?
DAC Consulting has specialised in customs and excise duties since 2007. If you are dealing with excise duty on mineral oils, tax warehouses, user undertakings or purchase permits, get in touch with us.