EMCS: Electronic Monitoring of Excise Goods Movements Now Affects Smaller Traders Too

More and more companies are moving excise goods through the EMCS system. How does the system work, and where does it hide tax risk for the consignor and the consignee?

In recent years, the market for alcoholic beverages, fuels and lubricants has boomed – not so much in volumes as in the breadth of the product range. A more varied offering has drawn into cross-border and domestic trade companies that previously had no experience with excise duties. Likewise, companies that already had such experience automatically extend their obligations to new products whenever they buy or sell them. It is enough, for example, to order a new lubricant from Austria or to send a seemingly trivial quantity of craft beer to the Czech Republic, and your obligations expand immediately. Sooner or later, all of these companies come up against the same system – EMCS. Handling it correctly is crucial for sensitive goods.

EMCS (Excise Movement and Control System) is an EU-wide electronic system that monitors the movement of goods subject to excise duty. It has been operating since 1 January 2011 and originally tracked mainly movements under a duty suspension arrangement – i.e. while the excise duty had not yet been paid. The system monitors not only cross-border movements within the EU, but also domestic movements from a domestic consignor to a domestic consignee. It covers alcoholic beverages, mineral oils and tobacco products.

Since 13 February 2023, however, the rules have been tightened. EMCS now also covers the movement of goods on which duty has already been paid and which have been released for consumption. In Slovakia, this has had a significant impact on fuels (duty-paid diesel and petrol), whose movements between distributors, retailers and consumers are monitored throughout the country. For other duty-paid goods, movements between EU Member States are monitored. Such movements are recorded by means of a simplified electronic administrative document (known in practice as an e-SAD).

The principle of EMCS under duty suspension is logical. Before the movement starts, the consignor issues an electronic administrative document (e-AD), the system assigns it an administrative reference code (ARC), and the goods may be moved only with it. After delivery, the consignee submits a report of receipt in the system, which officially closes the movement. The whole process resembles the customs transit procedure: the goods move with a deferred tax liability covered by a financial guarantee. Until the movement has been properly completed, the tax liability remains open. The only difference is that it is not a customs debt but excise duty.

It is precisely in the guarantee and in the proper completion of the movement that the greatest risk lies, one that can take traders by unpleasant surprise. Under EU legislation, the guarantee is as a rule provided by the consignor (e.g. an authorised warehousekeeper or a registered consignor). Only if the customs office allows it may the guarantee be provided by the transporter, the owner of the goods or the consignee. Whoever provided the guarantee bears the brunt in the event of irregularities and becomes liable to pay the duty. In the standard set-up, therefore, the duty for an uncompleted movement is borne by the consignor, not the buyer.

An irregularity arises if the goods do not arrive at their destination, are lost or a shortfall is found. At that moment, the tax liability arises. If it cannot be established where exactly the irregularity occurred, the duty is recovered in the Member State of dispatch.

The time limits are unforgiving. The consignee must submit the report of receipt within 5 working days of the end of the movement. If it fails to do so, the consignor has only 4 months to prove to the customs office that the movement was properly completed. If this period expires without result, the customs office will assess the duty against whoever provided the guarantee. A further three-year period runs for subsequent proof, but the authorities’ demand usually comes not after a few days but after months – at a time when the trader no longer expects any problem at all.

An administrative formality can thus quickly turn into a serious financial and contractual problem. We therefore recommend that commercial contracts clearly define who is the consignor in EMCS, who provides and finances the guarantee, and by when the consignee must submit the report of receipt.

If you are selling the goods and providing the guarantee, require financial cover in the contract in case the consignee does not confirm receipt in the system. If you are buying and providing the guarantee, factor this cost into the price – the guarantee will tie up your liquidity for weeks (even more so with mineral oils). Remember that in any dispute with the customs office, only the electronic record in the system counts, not a verbal assurance from the carrier.

As the product range grows and the rules become stricter, demand for EMCS advice is rising. Our company helps businesses that trade in these sensitive goods at home and abroad. We handle the necessary registrations, the issuing of electronic documents, the closing of movements in EMCS, the management of guarantees and representation before the customs office. The obligation to use EMCS applies from the very first movement of goods. If you deal with the legal rules in advance, you will avoid paying excise duty on goods that have long since left your hands.